Kummer–Vandiver conjecture

Kummer–Vandiver conjecture

Field	Algebraic number theory
Conjectured by	Ernst Kummer
Conjectured in	1849
Open problem	Yes

In mathematics, the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture, or Vandiver conjecture, states that a prime p does not divide the class number h_K of the maximal real subfield $K=\mathbb {Q} (\zeta _{p})^{+}$ of the p-th cyclotomic field. The conjecture was first made by Ernst Kummer on 28 December 1849 and 24 April 1853 in letters to Leopold Kronecker, reprinted in (Kummer 1975, pages 84, 93, 123–124), and independently rediscovered around 1920 by Philipp Furtwängler and Harry Vandiver (1946, p. 576),

As of 2011, there is no particularly strong evidence either for or against the conjecture and it is unclear whether it is true or false, though it is likely that counterexamples are very rare.

Background

The class number h of the cyclotomic field $\mathbb {Q} (\zeta _{p})$ is a product of two integers h₁ and h₂, called the first and second factors of the class number, where h₂ is the class number of the maximal real subfield $K=\mathbb {Q} (\zeta _{p})^{+}$ of the p-th cyclotomic field. The first factor h₁ is well understood and can be computed easily in terms of Bernoulli numbers, and is usually rather large. The second factor h₂ is not well understood and is hard to compute explicitly, and in the cases when it has been computed it is usually small.

Kummer showed that if a prime p does not divide the class number h, then Fermat's Last Theorem holds for exponent p.

The Kummer–Vandiver conjecture states that p does not divide the second factor h₂. Kummer showed that if p divides the second factor, then it also divides the first factor. In particular the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture holds for regular primes (those for which p does not divide the first factor).

Evidence for and against the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture

Kummer verified the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture for p less than 200, and Vandiver extended this to p less than 600. Joe Buhler, Richard Crandall, and Reijo Ernvall et al. (2001) verified it for p < 12 million. Buhler & Harvey (2011) extended this to primes less than 163 million, and Hart, Harvey & Ong (2017) extended this to primes less than 2³¹.

Washington (1996, p. 158) describes an informal probability argument, based on rather dubious assumptions about the equidistribution of class numbers mod p, suggesting that the number of primes less than x that are exceptions to the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture might grow like (1/2)log log x. This grows extremely slowly, and suggests that the computer calculations do not provide much evidence for Vandiver's conjecture: for example, the probability argument (combined with the calculations for small primes) suggests that one should only expect about 1 counterexample in the first 10¹⁰⁰ primes, suggesting that it is unlikely any counterexample will be found by further brute force searches even if there are an infinite number of exceptions.

Schoof (2003) gave conjectural calculations of the class numbers of real cyclotomic fields for primes up to 10000, which strongly suggest that the class numbers are not randomly distributed mod p. They tend to be quite small and are often just 1. For example, assuming the generalized Riemann hypothesis, the class number of the real cyclotomic field for the prime p is 1 for p<163, and divisible by 4 for p=163. This suggests that Washington's informal probability argument against the conjecture may be misleading.

Mihăilescu (2010) gave a refined version of Washington's heuristic argument, suggesting that the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture is probably true.

Consequences of the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture

Kurihara (1992) showed that the conjecture is equivalent to a statement in the algebraic K-theory of the integers, namely that K_n(Z) = 0 whenever n is a multiple of 4. In fact from the Kummer–Vandiver conjecture and the norm residue isomorphism theorem follow a full conjectural calculation of the K-groups for all values of n; see Quillen–Lichtenbaum conjecture for details.

See also

• Regular and irregular primes
• Herbrand–Ribet theorem

References

• Buhler, Joe; Crandall, Richard; Ernvall, Reijo; Metsänkylä, Tauno; Shokrollahi, M. Amin (2001), Bosma, Wieb (ed.), "Irregular primes and cyclotomic invariants to 12 million", Computational algebra and number theory (Proceedings of the 2nd International Magma Conference held at Marquette University, Milwaukee, WI, May 12–16, 1996), Journal of Symbolic Computation, 31 (1): 89–96, doi:10.1006/jsco.1999.1011, ISSN 0747-7171, MR 1806208
• Ghate, Eknath (2000), "Vandiver's conjecture via K-theory" (PDF), in Adhikari, S. D.; Katre, S. A.; Thakur, Dinesh (eds.), Cyclotomic fields and related topics, Proceedings of the Summer School on Cyclotomic Fields held in Pune, June 7–30, 1999, Bhaskaracharya Pratishthana, Pune, pp. 285–298, MR 1802389
• Buhler, J. P.; Harvey, D. (2011), "Irregular primes to 163 million", Mathematics of Computation, 80 (276): 2435–2444, arXiv:0912.2121, doi:10.1090/S0025-5718-2011-02461-0, MR 2813369
• Hart, William; Harvey, David; Ong, Wilson (2017), "Irregular primes to two billion", Mathematics of Computation, 86 (308): 3031–3049, arXiv:1605.02398, doi:10.1090/mcom/3211, MR 3667037, S2CID 37245286
• Kummer, Ernst Eduard (1975), Weil, André (ed.), Collected papers. Volume 1: Contributions to Number Theory, Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag, ISBN 978-0-387-06835-0, MR 0465760
• Kurihara, Masato (1992), "Some remarks on conjectures about cyclotomic fields and K-groups of Z", Compositio Mathematica, 81 (2): 223–236, ISSN 0010-437X, MR 1145807
• Mihăilescu, Preda (2010), Turning Washington's heuristics in favor of Vandiver's conjecture, arXiv:1011.6283, Bibcode:2010arXiv1011.6283M
• Schoof, René (2003), "Class numbers of real cyclotomic fields of prime conductor", Mathematics of Computation, 72 (242): 913–937, doi:10.1090/S0025-5718-02-01432-1, ISSN 0025-5718, MR 1954975
• Vandiver, H. S. (1946), "Fermat's last theorem. Its history and the nature of the known results concerning it", The American Mathematical Monthly, 53 (10): 555–578, doi:10.1080/00029890.1946.11991754, ISSN 0002-9890, JSTOR 2305236, MR 0018660
• Washington, Lawrence C. (1996), Introduction to Cyclotomic Fields, Springer, ISBN 978-0-387-94762-4